Immediate Reaction
First of all, congratulations to both the furd and Cal women. I did not see the women’s game (I followed it intermittently on gamecast), but a 20 point victory that was a blowout all the way is an achievement. Good job furds. To the Cal women, you are still in sole possession of 1st place despite the setback, with all of the road games against top Pac-10 opponents in the books. Take care of business the rest of the way the conference is yours.
As for the men’s game…WOW. Wow. I think I’m still shaking with rage. For those of you who do not know Dave Libbey, tonight was a great introduction. He is a referee, and a notorious one at that, even by Pac-10 standards. You see, little Dave wanted to be a basketball player. He tried very, very hard, worked on his game with obsessive zeal but despite his efforts, he could not become an impact player. Now all grown up, Mr. Libbey affects games all the same, but he is not an undersized small forward, nor a great three point shooter. No, he is what I call an impact referee. Instead of simply letting the game flow and calling fouls when applicable, Mr. Libbey likes to insert himself into the game. He likes to dictate the tempo of the game, the style of the game, the emotion of the game. He is a narcissist, the absolute worst quality in a referee. The players are the ones who should decide the game but Mr. Libbey likes the attention on himself, when he should be an observer.
Tonight, Mr. Libbey and his crew decided the game by calling 21 fouls (21 !!!!!!!!!) on Cal in the second half. You might say, "But CBKWit, surely many of those fouls occured in the waning minutes, as Cal tried to extend the game." You are right. 5 of those fouls did come within the last 70 seconds. That leaves (only) 16 fouls over the first 19 minutes of the second half. Stanford was in the double bonus (10+ fouls on Cal) halfway through the second half. They shot 19 more free throws than Cal, at Haas!
Every time Brook Lopez touched the ball, it was a foul or a bucket. The refs made sure of this by calling fouls after the play if Lopez happened to miss, a particularly infuriating tactic (witness Hardin’s last foul, after he scored 4 straight points to pull Cal within 2). On the other end, Randle did a great job drawing obvious fouls on whichever terrible furd point guard tried to guard him, but all of the contact by the furds in the lane was somehow admissible. Not once did you hear a whistle as the furds pulled us or went through us for offensive boards. As time expired, all I could do was laugh.
I’m interested in hearing reactions from any lurking furd fans. If the shoe was on the other foot, I’d certainly be happy (a win’s a win), but I’d also be more relieved than excited and willing to admit that we caught a break. Maybe I’m crazy, and I’m definitely biased, but that was the worst officiated half of any sporting event I can immediately recall. Furds, your thoughts? I also think a "worst officiated game" post/thread is in order; it might be therapeutic
We’ll have more of a recap on the actual game within the next 36 hours. There were other reasons why we lost the game (notably, terrible rebounding and lack of ball pressure on entry passes), but even though I think it’s time for a new coach, I can’t pin this loss on Braun. Dave Libbey, I hope you’re happy; all I’m thinking about is you.


